Recruitment Relevations From Social Recruiting Conference 2011 (#SRCONF)

Posted July 04, 2011 - By | 9 Comments


The worst thing that can happen from any gathering of minds is come away thinking that we have all the questions answered. Far better to come away with new questions buzzing in your mind that you hadn’t think to ask before. From the Social Recruiting Conference 2011 (#SRCONF) last week – superbly hosted by Vic Okezie and Alan Whitford – the stirrings of these ideas – nay, relevations – on social recruiting have come to my mind.

1. It’s recruitment With the small r & Marketing with a big M.

adventure 08 300x168 Recruitment Relevations From Social Recruiting Conference 2011 (#SRCONF)

We’ve been hearing a lot about the need for recruiters to develop marketing skills and all of the big brands on show at #SRCONF made mention of it in their presentations last week. I think we are perhaps closer than we might realise to the point where recruitment actually becomes marketing, where the acquisition of candidates is a welcome but secondary outcome for any major recruitment campaign. This idea – pretty close to outrageous so long ago – becomes clearer when you consider an organisation like one of those who presented on stage – an Accenture, for example, a consultancy business who’s always depended upon the power of it’s brand within the extended community of the like minded. We can speculate that for an organisation like this, a recruitment need can become a major marketing opportunity. Need to recruit 100 graduates? Extend your recruitment campaign to bring in 10,000, provide a great experience throughout the journey and embed within them your values as a business. You might end up 100 great hires, but your biggest gain is an army of brand advocates who will no doubt go on to work for many of your client or prospective client businesses. In effect, you may be seeding your client base with allies of your brand.

In line with Matt Jeffrey’s contention that recruitment should formally become a function of marketing rather than HR, this is recruitment marketing with a small r and a big M. The implications for us, as recruiters, is profound. We need to find new skills in marcomms, community engagement and relationship management. Or it won’t be us doing the ‘recruitment’ at all.

2. The CV Chains Us To The Desktop; Mobile Recruiting Won’t Be Here Until It Goes

chained to desk 300x201 Recruitment Relevations From Social Recruiting Conference 2011 (#SRCONF)

It’s unusual to have great presentations, delivered by two popular and charismatic presenters, somehow ending up a little bit flat.

Pepsico’s mobile app – developed by UK mobile recruitment leaders, topbananas – has certainly pushed the marble along when it come to mobile recruiting but it lacked the key feature which prevented it from being a triumph – you couldn’t apply through it. This is a critical break in the candidate journey, and it made the whole case study a little less revolutionary than perhaps we anticipated. Can a mobile app be considered truly mobile recruiting if, in the end, you are directing your job applicant to return to the desktop and apply, presumably by email and with Word? The overwhelming sentiment of the crowd was ‘no’.

This led me think of the role the CV plays in keeping job seekers chained to the desktop. You will never be able to download a Word document onto your phone (and thank f___ for that, imagine if Windows had ever won the phone war?), and so until the industry itself evolves beyond the idea that candidates must at some stage in the application process send in a CV, mobile will remain where Pepsico & topbananas have left it – a great promotional, recruitment marketing and employer branding tool, but not a genuine mobile recruiting app.


3. Size & Hiring Frequency Matters in Social Recruiting

professioncards 300x149 Recruitment Relevations From Social Recruiting Conference 2011 (#SRCONF)

The point was made during the Social Media Strategy Debate segment by industry veteran Keith Robinson, that a great deal of the lessons provided at #SRCONF could not be applied to the small or infrequent hirer. This seems self evidently true, but is consistently underplayed on the conference scene. For a company that hires 1 person every 3 years, it makes no sense to invest in the building of any type of community for the purpose. Size matters in social recruiting, and hiring frequency matters more. The social recruiting initiatives described by the likes of Accenture, Societe General, Unilver and the rest have no bearing for the vast majority of companies out there. And so we have an urgent need to remove from the conversation the sweeping statements that so often plague our community. They are unhelpful when we consider the sheer number of employers out there are something other than MNC sized megacorps we inevitably focus on in showcase conferences like #SRCONF. The butcher, the baker and the candle stick maker – the modern day SMB’s – will continue to be dependent on what they perceive to be the turnkey solutions – staff provided by 3rd party recruitment agencies or candidate traffic driven through job board advertising.

4. Brand Based Talent Communities? More Questions Than Answers

blackdot illusion 300x230 Recruitment Relevations From Social Recruiting Conference 2011 (#SRCONF)

The concept of a Talent Community based round a corporate employer brand has been under strong challenge this year. It’s worth exploring again here, as all the case studies presented at #SRCONF remain based around the conventional notion – that is, you build a Talent Community as an extension of your corporate brand. As panelist Gareth Jones of BruBakerHR has recently argued, this may be building a community around the wrong idea of the job seeker. Read his excellent blog post for a clearer exposition of the thesis. The job seeker is not a permanent category of person, nor even a category that people willingly embrace. It’s a transition phase that most people are keen to get out of as soon as possible. So what happens when the job seeker you’ve brought to your Talent Community, and have been engaging with for so long, actually get’s a job somewhere else? Brand advocate or not, he’s going to disappear. For a global brand like Accenture, who in my speculation may already have been moving down the road to using Talent Community’s primarily as a marketing hub, this may be the enough. But for most other businesses who’s need is primarily to, you know, recruit the people, it might make not make much sense to invest resources and continual commitment in building permanent assets for a ‘community’ that is transient and brand agnostic, and may, in the end, not be a much of a community at all. The argument might be to move into communities that already exist – as Jones indeed argues – those that have self organised around a trade or some other vector that was important to the community. Does this not then offer the 3rd party recruitment agent – routinely, and often correctly, lambasted for being steadfast in their hostility to change – a route back to relevance on the social web? It should for the smart ones, who are now moving into those verticals and building their credibility as fully fledged members of that community


5. Success Cannot Be Your Only Teacher

screwup 300x225 Recruitment Relevations From Social Recruiting Conference 2011 (#SRCONF)

Perhaps the biggest cheer of the day was reserved for Katie McNab, Talent Acquisition Manager at Pepsico when she gamely ventured that she didn’t know everything, made mistakes and were learning as she went. It was important to hear. Too often, we hear of the unalloyed triumph of organisations delivering social recruiting projects, with the reverses minimized and the successes burnished for display. It is the nature of the beast, of course, but the display of success alone can be a poor teacher if it is not also accompanied with equally compelling examination and exposition of the mistakes and errors that were made.

Social Recruiting – change of any type – is risky. It’s only with a balanced understanding of those risks that we will be able to alleviate the cynicism that continues to pervade in HR and recruitment landscape when the topic of social recruiting comes up.

Perhaps what we need is another type of conference – the How Not To Do Social Recruiting Conference 2012 or the ‘Look, Here’s How I Fucked This Social Recruiting Project Up’ Conference 2014? Come Vic, Alan, and the rest – when are we going to get to go to one of the those? I’d buy a ticket. Wouldn’t you?

logo grey1 300x88 Recruitment Relevations From Social Recruiting Conference 2011 (#SRCONF)


Wise Man Say helps recruiters use Social Media. Contact me on 0207 739 9358 or email on hung.lee@wisemansay.co.uk for more information

If you liked this post…….like it!

Published under : Essays, Social Recruiting | Tagged with : ,

9 Comments

  • Ken July 04, 2011

    Mr Lee, interesting commentary, FYI you can download a word document on your phone:
    http://download.cnet.com/Documents-To-Go-Office-Suite/3000-2124_4-10921089.html
    I was wondering what your thought were RE the marketing recruitment amalgamation for SME’s and the like, or is it only applicable for the like of Accenture or other blue chips?
    Cheers,
    Ken

  • Hung July 04, 2011

    Hi Ken,

    Thanks for your comment, great to see you on here. And thanks for the link – that I did not know. Having seen it now, I am very pleased that the idea of downloading documents to the phone never took off – a nightmare vision compared to the cloud!

    It’s a topical point on how recruitment + marketing can work for SME’s. I think it works best for the blue chips – perhaps especially consultancies – simply because of the scale. You can create many more brand advocates by being able to hold an Accenture style recruitment event, whereas a smaller organisation with a single seat hire, might have limited reach. That said, we’ve seen SME’s and start up’s conduct highly creative campaigns for a single hire, which subsequently gave the business a fantastic amount of marketing ‘buzz’. We are also seeing the development of collaborative recruitment campaigns where like minded SME’s come together a create a recruitment event for the purposes of both finding talent and promoting their businesses. So the short answer is, yes, it’s applicable but you may have to be more creative with the idea to make it work.

    Thanks for the comment, let’s speak soon.

    Best wishes

    Hung

  • Vic Okezie July 04, 2011

    Hi Hung, excellent review and many thanks for your support with SRCONF, before the conference and on the day too. Your highlights is spot on wrt contents & conversations from the conference.

    Regarding the SMEs, this was also observed by a few and we will have to identify if there are compelling case studies out there. Will surely ask for suggestions and see if we can find ones to feature next time. The reality is, most of the companies who tend to invest in Social Media for Employer branding / Recruitment are usually ones with a fat wallet. However, hopefully some SMEs can learn from The Challenge (a charity) run by ex-Googler Doug Fraley which runs on a very tight budget?

    About your suggested ‘failure-themed’ conferences on Social Recruiting, I shall leave that to other people who are a lot smarter than me :-) Thanks Hung.

  • Marc Mapes July 04, 2011

    Hung,

    Good stuff as always. Really enjoyed the #SRConf staged by Vic and Alan (with a little help by you). The event was very interesting with some great insight from some of the biggest players in the social recruitment world. I think the next couple of years will be very telling in how far social recruitment will go with those who don’t have massive budgets. Taking from The Challenge’s success, it would be great to see another SME or two on the panel next year talking about their successful (or unsuccessful even) methods and channels they used. Like most things, social recruitment won’t be deemed a successful until it becomes a method of choice for non-globals.

    Best,

    @marcmapes

  • Hung July 04, 2011

    Thanks Marc, glad you enjoyed the conference. I agree that the Challenge’s case study was particularly interesting – social media on a shoe string! Let’s hope there is access to Doug Fraley’s presentation.

    Thanks for your comment

    Best wishes

    Hung

  • Pingback
    5 Best Recruitment Marketing Articles of the Week 7.2.11 to 7.8.11 « Recruitment Marketing Innovation, Technology and Ideas July 08, 2011

    [...] Recruitment Takeaways from the Social Recruiting Conference 2011 by Hung Lee (@Wise_Man_Say) [...]

  • Pingback
    #SRCONF 2011: Press Reviews & Blog Reactions / Social Recruiting Conference 2011 / Social Media in Recruiting Conference / #SRCONF 2011 July 14, 2011

    [...] Hung Lee (WiseManSay) excellently reviewed the conference with highlights on some of the topics that may be relevant for future events. Recruitment Revelations from Social Recruiting Conference [...]

  • Pingback
    Breaking: Crexia’s Website Changes! / Social Media Conferences for HR, Recruiting, Learning & Social Workplace by Crexia July 25, 2011

    [...] 2011 had a fantastic review by Ri5.co.uk including several other blogs and reflections written about the [...]

  • Pingback
    #SRCONF 2011: Press & Blogger Reviews | Social Media in HR Conferences, Social Recruiting, Social Learning & Social Workplace August 10, 2011

    [...] Hung Lee (WiseManSay) excellently reviewed the conference with highlights on some of the topics that may be relevant for future events. Recruitment Revelations from Social Recruiting Conference [...]

Leave a Reply